Clicky

Purina vs Royal Canin: Which one is the Best?

Both Purina and Royal Canin are well-known pet food brands. But which one is better? It really depends on your pet’s individual needs. Here’s a look at the key differences between Purina and Royal Canin to help you decide which brand is right for your pet.

Purina vs Royal Canin: Companies’ History Comparison

Purina was founded in 1894 as Robinson-Danforth Commission Company and later changed its name to Ralston Purina in 1902. The 128-year-old company is based in St. Louis, Missouri, and is now a subsidiary of Nestle.

On the other hand, Royal Canin has only been around since 1968 having been founded by French veterinary surgeon Jean Cathary in the Gard region in France. It was started by a veterinarian with the aim of providing better nutrition for dogs.

Royal Canin’s HQ in the US is St. Charles in Missouri. It has manufacturing facilities in Missouri and South Dakota and offices all across the country. 

Purina vs Royal Canin: Product Offerings Comparison

Purina offers a wide variety of both dog and cat food products under different brands such as Purina One, Purina Pro Plan, and PurinaOn the other hand, Royal Canin has been in existence for over 50 years having been established in 1968. The company provides a wide range of pet food products for both dogs and cats.

Purina’s primary focus is on providing affordable, high-quality pet foods. The company offers over 400 different types of pet food products.

In contrast, Royal Canin focuses on providing customized nutrition for pets based on their individual needs. The company offers over 200 types of pet food products.

Formulas Comparison

Purina’s dog food formulas are based on three key principles: high-quality ingredients, stringent safety standards, and targeted nutrition.

Royal Canin’s dog food formulas are based on the following:

– Providing customized nutrition for dogs based on their individual needs

– Use of high-quality ingredients

– Strict safety standards

Some of the common formulas offered by Purina include Puppy Chow, Dog Chow, and Beneful.

Royal Canin’s formula offerings include sizes, breeds, ages, and special needs. For example, the company offers formulas for small dogs, large dogs, puppies, adult dogs, and senior dogs.

Key differences between Purina and Royal Canin

  1. Purina has a variety of brands: Purina One, Purina Pro Plan, and Purina Royal Canin has a focus on customized nutrition for pets based on their individual needs Purina offers over 400 types of pet food products while Royal Canin offers over 200
  2. Custom recipes: While both companies offer formulas for different life stages, Royal Canin provides options for specific size, breed, ages, and special needs.
  3. Pricing Comparison: Purina’s products are generally more affordable than Royal Canin’s. For example, a 28-pound bag of Purina Dog Chow costs $24.99 while a 17-pound bag of Royal Canin Size Health Nutrition Small Adult dry dog food costs $54.99.
  4. Specialized nutrition: Purina’s Purina One and Purina Pro plans are geared towards providing specialized nutrition for specific needs such as weight control, sensitive stomachs, and more. Royal Canin also provides specialized nutrition formulas for things like joint health, indoor cats, and more.

What’s not great about Purina

  • Controversial ingredients: Some of Purina’s formulas have come under fire for containing controversial ingredients such as corn, soy, and by-products. Other controversial ingredients present in Purina recipes include artificial colors and dyes which have no nutritional value to pets.
  • Recalls: Purina has had several recalls over the years including a 2012 recall for salmonella contamination and a 2007 recall for melamine contamination.
  • Use of fillers: Purina has been criticized for overusing soybean, corn, and wheat meal as fillers. These ingredients are often used to bulk up formulas and can be hard for pets to digest.

What’s not great about Royal Canin

  • High prices: Royal Canin’s products are generally more expensive than Purina’s. Some of their recipes such as Royal Canin Veterinary Diet Adult Skin Support Dry Dog Food go for over $150.
  • Use of by-products: Some of Royal Canin’s formulas contain by-products which are considered to be low-quality ingredients. By-products can include things like feet, feathers, and organs.
  • Use of low-quality grains such as brewers’ rice: While not all of Royal Canin’s formulas contain low-quality grains, some of them do. Low-quality grains such as brewers’ rice can be hard for pets to digest and may cause health problems.

Recalls: Purina vs Royal Canin

Purina has had more recalls compared to Royal Canin. Purina Beneful was recalled in 2007 for melamine contamination, and in 2012 for salmonella contamination. While Royal Canin has had no recalls in recent years, the company did have a recall in 2006 for vitamin D3 toxicity.

Over the past 10 years, Purina has been recalled more than 5 times which is significantly higher than Royal Canins’.

Puppy Formulas: Purina Pro vs Royal Canin

Royal Canin has 23 products specifically formulated for puppies while Purina Pro has only 10 products. Royal Canin’s products are breed-specific while Purina Pro’s line of products are geared towards puppies of different sizes of dogs such as small-size, medium and large-size breeds.

Bottom line:

For puppies, you’re better off with Royal Canin. The company has more products to choose from and their formulas are breed-specific.

Adult Formulas: Purina Pro vs Royal Canin

Royal Canin has a whooping 96 products formulated for adults while Purina Pro only has 23 products for adults. Royal Canin’s options are wider with over 40 vet options and several flavors such as duck, kangaroo, rabbit, veggie, and venison.

Bottom line:

For adult dogs, you’re better off with Royal Canin. The company has more products to choose from and their formulas are more specialized.

Weight Control Formulas: Purina One vs Royal Canin

Purina One has 3 products specifically for weight control while Royal Canin has 11. Purina One’s products are only available in dry food form while Royal Canin has both dry and wet food options.

Senior Formulas: Purina Pro vs Royal Canin

Purina Pro has 3 senior-specific diets for dogs while Royal Canin has 11.

Canned Formulas: Purina Pro vs Royal Canin

Purina Pro has 46 canned food options while Royal Canin has almost double – 73 canned formulas for dogs of all stages.

Which one is best?

There is no easy answer when it comes to deciding between Purina and Royal Canin. Both brands have their pros and cons. However, if we had to choose one, we would go with Royal Canin because they have more specialized formulas for different life stages and needs. They also have a greater variety of flavors which can make mealtime more enjoyable for your dog.

When it comes to price, Purina is the better option. Their products are generally less expensive than Royal Canin’s.

If you’re looking for a brand with fewer recalls, then Purina is the way to go. However, if you’re willing to overlook a few recalls, then Royal Canin is the better choice because they have more formulas to choose from.

In the end, the best way to decide between Purina and Royal Canin is to talk to your veterinarian and figure out what’s best for your dog’s individual needs.

FAQ on Purina vs Royal Canin vs Others

Q: Purina vs IAMs

A: Iams is a subsidiary of Procter & Gamble, while Purina is owned by Nestle. Iams has been around since 1946 and offers a wide variety of products for dogs and cats. Iams was one of the first companies to use animal-based proteins in their pet food formulas.

Purina has been around since 1894 and offers a wide variety of products for both dogs and cats. Purina is known for their “Beggin’ Strips” which are popular among dog owners.

When it comes to price, Iams is the cheaper option. Iams also has more formulas specifically for weight control and senior pets. However, Purina has more canned food options.

Q: Purina vs Science diet

A: Science Diet is a subsidiary of Hill’s Pet Nutrition, while Purina is owned by Nestle. Science Diet was founded in 1930 and offers a wide variety of products for dogs and cats. Science Diet is known for their “prescription” diets which are formulaic diets that are only available through veterinarians.

Purina has been around since 1894 and offers a wide variety of products for both dogs and cats.

When it comes to price, Science Diet is the more expensive option. However, Science Diet offers more formulas specifically for weight control and senior pets. Purina has more canned food options.

Q: Purina vs Blue buffalo

A: Blue Buffalo is a privately-owned company, while Purina is owned by Nestle. Blue Buffalo was founded in 2002 and offers a wide variety of products for dogs and cats. Blue Buffalo is known for their “Life Protection Formula” which is a line of products that are designed to be “holistic.”

Purina has been around since 1894 and offers a wide variety of products for both dogs and cats.

When it comes to price, Blue Buffalo is the more expensive option. Blue Buffalo also offers more formulas specifically for weight control and senior pets. However, Purina has more canned food options.

Q: Purina vs Eukanuba

A: Eukanuba is a subsidiary of Procter & Gamble, while Purina is owned by Nestle. Eukanuba was founded in 1969 and offers a wide variety of products for dogs. Eukanuba is known for their “Performance Formulas” which are designed for active dogs.

Purina has been around since 1894 and offers a wide variety of products for both dogs and cats.

When it comes to price, Purina is the cheaper option. Eukanuba also offers more formulas specifically for weight control and senior pets. However, Purina has more canned food options.

Q: Purina vs Wellness

A: Wellness is a subsidiary of WellPet, while Purina is owned by Nestle. Wellness was founded in 1997 and offers a wide variety of products for dogs and cats. Wellness is known for their “Core” line of products which are designed to be nutrient-rich.

When it comes to price, Wellness is the more expensive option. Wellness also offers more formulas specifically for weight control and senior pets. However, Purina has more canned food options.

Purina vs Pedigree: Which one is Better?

Comparing Purina and Pedigree pet food is like comparing apples to oranges and is actually quite easy to come up with the winner. While they are both ‘fruits’, they have different flavors, textures, and nutritional values.

What is Purina?

Purina is a pet food company that produces both dog and cat food. They have been in business for over 120 years and are one of the most well-known pet food companies in the world. It was founded in 1894 in St. Louis Missouri. Purina has a wide variety of products that cater to different dogs’ and cats’ needs, including those with allergies or special dietary requirements.

What is Pedigree?

Pedigree is a UK pet food company that specializes in dog food and was founded in 1957. In 1968, Mars Incorporated bought the company and it has been owned by them ever since. Pedigree is known for their affordable, mass-produced dog food that is sold in most supermarkets.

The firm is based in England and sells more pet food than any other company on the planet, alongside its other flagship brand such as Sheba, Eukanuba, Cesar, IAMS, and Nutro that are all owned by Mars Inc.

What’s great about Pedigree:

Affordability:

Since Pedigree is mass-produced pet food, it is very affordable compared to other brands.

Availability: Pedigree is sold in most supermarkets, making it very accessible for pet owners.

Variety: Pedigree offers a wide variety of products to cater to different dogs’ needs, including those with allergies or special dietary requirements.

What’s great about Purina:

Quality: Purina is a well-known and trusted pet food company that has been in business for over 120 years. They use high-quality ingredients in their products.

Variety: Purina has a wide variety of products to cater to different dogs’ and cats’ needs, including those with allergies or special dietary requirements.

Nutrition: Purina products are nutritionally balanced to provide your pet with the nutrients they need.

Nutrients comparison: Purina vs Pedigree:

The protein and fat content of both Purina’s wet and dry food are lower, on average, by about 6% than Pedigree. The protein proportion in their kibble is around 26%, which is far less than Purina’s 32% and 18%. The protein concentration in Pedigree’s wet food is approximately 41%, which is also significantly lower than Purina’s 54%.

The carbohydrates in Pedigree’s dry food are about 4% higher than Purina. The moisture content in their kibble is about 10% higher on average, too.

In terms of vitamins and minerals, Purina contains more vitamin A, B12, D3, E, biotin, and niacin. It also contains more calcium, phosphorus, and sodium.

Purina is the clear winner when it comes to nutrition. Their products are nutritionally balanced to provide your pet with the nutrients they need.

Ingredients comparison: Purina vs Pedigree

When it comes to ingredients, Purina is the clear winner. Their products are made with high-quality, natural ingredients.

Purina’s dry food contains chicken, turkey, duck, fish meal, and beef fat. It also contains peas, carrots, potatoes, rice, and flaxseed.

Pedigree’s dry food contains chicken by-product meal, corn gluten meal, soybean meal, and beef fat. It also contains wheat flour, corn syrup, and artificial colors and flavors.

When it comes to wet food, Purina’s products contain chicken, turkey, duck, fish, and beef. They also contain peas, carrots, potatoes, and rice.

Pedigree’s wet food products contain chicken by-product meal, corn gluten meal, soybean meal, and beef fat. They also contain wheat flour, corn syrup, and artificial colors and flavors.

Purina is the clear winner when it comes to ingredients. Their products are made with high-quality, natural ingredients.

Price comparison: Purina vs Pedigree

Purina’s dry food is more expensive than Pedigree’s, on average. However, their wet food is about the same price.

Pedigree’s dry food is cheaper than Purina’s, on average. However, their wet food is about the same price.

When it comes to price, it is a Pedigree is cheaper but consider value, not just cost.

Formulas: Purina vs Pedigree

Purina is a clear winner when it comes to the number of pet food formulations currently available on sale. At the time of this writing, they offer 194 different formulas. This is significantly more than Pedigree’s 120 formulas.

Purina has several brands but has organized its products under 3 major business lines; Purina Dog Chow, Purina ONE, and Purina Pro Plan.

Recalls, Purina vs Pedigree:

Purina has had 5 recalls in the past 10 years while Pedigree has had 3 recalls in the past 10 years.

When it comes to safety, both brands are at par, despite Purina having more recalls over the past 10 years.

Locations;

Purina is almost exclusively in the US while Pedigree has operations in over 50 countries.

Purina has a strong online presence and offers home delivery in the contiguous US while Pedigree does not have an e-commerce platform.

Which one is better?

Purina is the better brand, hands down. Their products are made with high-quality, natural ingredients and are nutritionally balanced to provide your pet with the nutrients they need. They also have a wide variety of formulas to choose from, so you can find the perfect one for your pet’s needs. And if you’re looking for convenience, you can even have their products delivered right to your door.

FAQs on Purina vs Pedigree vs Others

Q: Purina vs Royal canin?

A: There is no clear winner when it comes to Purina vs Royal Canin. Both brands offer high-quality products that are nutritionally balanced and made with natural ingredients. However, Purina has a wider variety of formulas to choose from, so you may be able to find one that better suits your pet’s needs. Additionally, Purina offers home delivery in the contiguous US, while Royal Canin does not have an e-commerce platform.

Q: Which one to get, purina or pedigree?

A: Go for Purina is you can pay a bit extra. You will be getting natural ingredients, a wide variety of formulas, and the convenience of home delivery. Pedigree is cheaper but you get what you pay for in terms of quality and variety.

Q: Is Purina better than the hills science diet?

A: Yes, Purina is a better brand than Hills Science Diet. Their products are made with high-quality, natural ingredients and are nutritionally balanced to provide your pet with the nutrients they need. They also have a wide variety of formulas to choose from, so you can find the perfect one for your pet’s needs. Additionally, Purina offers home delivery in the contiguous US, while Hills Science Diet does not have an e-commerce platform.

Nulo Freestyle vs Nulo Metal Series

Nulo Freestyle and Nulo Medal Series are two different types of feed for dogs to consider. One is inexpensive dog food, with the other is a high-quality diet that can be used as your pet’s sole source of nutrition.

Nulo Freestyle vs Nulo MetalSeries

Nulo Freestyle is a low-cost alternative to many name brands, but it still offers quality ingredients. The kibble is made with whole grains, chicken, and vegetables. It also has added vitamins and minerals for your dog’s health.

Nulo Medal Series is a bit more expensive, but it is a complete and balanced diet that contains all the nutrients your dog needs to stay healthy. The kibble is made with high-quality ingredients, including deboned chicken, salmon, and sweet potatoes. It also has added vitamins and minerals for your dog’s health.

Though Nulo brand is committed to high protein, low carbohydrate foods, Nulo Freestyle offers greater variety and more options in texture and consistency than Nulo MetalSeries.

Nulo Freestyle is available at major retail outlets while Nulo Metalseries is exclusively sold at Petsmart

Medalseries is available in 4.5 LB, 11 LB AND 24 LB BAGS while Freestyle is available in 4.5 LB, 6 LB*, 11 LB, 24 LB, & 26 LB* BAGS.

Freestyle’s salmon & peas grain-free recipes includes 80% animal-based proteins while Metal Series has 82% animal protein

So, which is better for your dog? Ultimately, the decision comes down to budget and your dog’s individual needs. If you are looking for a complete and balanced diet that is affordable, then Nulo Freestyle is a great option. However, if you are willing to spend a bit more on your dog’s food, then Nulo Medal Series is the way to go. Whichever you choose, you can be confident that you are providing your dog with quality nutrition.

Here is a link to Freestyle and MetalSeries on their website.

About Nulo

Nulo was started by a group of passionate pet parents who believe that all dogs deserve to live happy, healthy lives. Michael, the founder of Nulo, was inspired to create a pet food company after watching his own dog suffer from a host of health problems. After doing some research, he realized that the vast majority of pet foods on the market are made with low-quality ingredients and fillers. This inspired him to create Nulo, a pet food company that is committed to providing dogs with the highest quality nutrition possible.

Blue Buffalo vs. American Journey

Blue Buffalo vs. American Journey

Both American Journey and Blue Buffalo claim to offer healthy foods for your feline and canine. And true to their word, they use premium ingredients with a basketful of health benefits to your pets. That, however, does not mean that they are equal. So, is American Journey better than Blue Buffalo?

American Journey is a pet food company that was founded in 2017 by Michael Day and Ryan Cohen which makes it one of the youngest in its industry. The brand is owned by Chewy Inc. which is among the largest pet products online stores.

Blue Buffalo vs. American Journey Ingredients

On the one hand, American Journey stands out on dry matter basis against Blue Buffalo which is why its foods have higher nutritional value. It contains 2.3%, 1.3%, 2.9%, and 8.1% higher protein content in dry dog, wet dog, dry cat, and wet cat foods, respectively. Both brands use premium ingredients but have 3 common controversial ones with 5 unique ones in Blue and 4 in the latter.

Blue Buffalo vs. American Journey Recalls

And while Blue Buffalo has been recalled 9 times, American Journey has zero recalls. After all, it is a baby in the field.

Blue Buffalo vs. American Journey Pricing

There is not much difference in their product prices anyway.

Blue Buffalo vs. American Journey comparison Table

FactorBlue BuffaloNutro
TasteUses meat, has tasty meals, but that differs based on recipesUse more meat with more protein content making tasty meals
Nutritional ValueNo fillers but high protein are available in one product lineNo fillers and it has more protein in all its formulas
Product LineSix product lines: Freedom, Basics, Veterinary Diet, Wilderness, Carnivora & TrueSolutionsLess than the competitor
PriceModerately priced & available in most stores onlineModerately priced but only available on Chewy
SafetyVery many recalls, 9 to be exact (2007 – 2017 )None

Verdict:

Overall, American Journey has the upper hand for having zero recalls but both brands use premium ingredients. 

Blue Buffalo vs. Canidae 2022

Blue Buffalo vs. Canidae

Both Canidae and Blue Buffalo use excellent ingredients to make their pet foods which explains why they are among the most reputable brands in the market. But there must, however, be factors that make one better than the other. So, who wins in the showdown?

Blue Buffalo vs. Canidae Companies

Since its founding in 1996, San Luis Obispo, CA, the U.S. by John Gordon and Scott Whipple, Canidae has made a name for itself for the production of high-quality and reliable pet foods. In fact, the brand has very many positive reviews which would explain their fame in the pet food industry. They even have Canidae Farms where they grow their ingredients for making pet foods.

On the other hand, Blue Buffalo was founded more than a decade after Merrick in 2003 by Bill Bishop and in 2018, it was sold to General Mills. It is headquartered in Connecticut, USA but has operations in more than 5 countries.

Blue Buffalo vs. Canidae Ingredients

The two brands seem to tie with minimal difference in the dry matter basis of both cat and dog foods. Canidae has 0.7%, 1.7%, 0.8%, and 3.9% higher protein content in dry dog food, wet dog food, dry cat food, and wet cat foods. This gives it more nutritional value than Blue Buffalo. They use good ingredients but both have 4 common controversial ones. However, Canidae has 3 unique against Blue Buffalo’s 4 controversial ingredients in their diets. On the one hand, Canidae has been recalled once for salmonella contamination against Blue Buffalo’s 9 times.

Blue Buffalo vs. Canidae Pricing

And while their pricing is almost similar, Canidae’s wet dog food is very expensive compared to Blue’s.

Blue Buffalo vs. Canidae Comparison Table

FactorBlue BuffaloCanidae
TasteUses meats for great taste enriched with veggiesFocuses on real meats plus some veggies for a great taste
Nutritional ValueHigh-quality ingredients with zero fillers but has some ingredients that are very controversialReceives loads of positive reviews due to quality ingredients. Has higher fat and protein content.
Product LineSix product lines: Freedom, Basics, Veterinary Diet, Wilderness, Carnivora & TrueSolutions57 dog food products & 17 cat food products
PriceFairly costlyExpensive
SafetyVery many recalls, 9 to be exact (2007 – 2017 )One recall in 2016

Blue Buffalo Freedom vs Canidae Pure Elements (video)

Verdict:

Overall, both brands are good choices but we lean more on Canidae despite the high price tags due to the nutritional value and safety.

Blue Buffalo vs. Blue Wilderness 2022

Blue Wilderness is one of Blue Buffalo’s categories of pet foods but we’ll delve into the differences in this article.

Blue Wilderness vs Blue Buffalo

Blue Wilderness brand has high protein composition and is grain-free while Blue Buffalo is composed of proteins and fewer protein ingredients. That’s the major difference between the two Blue Wilderness having a higher amount of protein content and all formulas are grain-free.

Also, Blue Buffalo contains both dog and cat foods but Blue Wilderness is a variant of the brand’s dog foods. It tries to mimic your pet’s instinctive diet which mainly contains meat. To enhance the food’s taste, the brand uses natural flavors like Parsley and Rosemary.

Both the Blue Wilderness and regular Blue Buffalo line of products consist of LifeSource Bits which is an ideal blend of vitamins, minerals, and antioxidants. This helps support a healthy immune system and promote overall health. As you would expect, there would be a significant difference in the products depending on what you choose. Unlike regular Blue Buffalo products, Blue Wilderness contains less omega-6 fatty acids but more crude fat and fiber.

Blue Buffalo vs. Blue Wilderness Comparison Table

FactorBlue BuffaloBlue Wilderness
TasteUses meat, has tasty meals, but that differs based on recipesContains higher protein and fat contents making it more palatable
Nutritional ValueHigh-quality ingredients with zero fillers & include omegasMore nutritious with healthy ingredients, omegas & no fillers
Product LineSix product lines: Freedom, Basics, Veterinary Diet, Wilderness, Carnivora & TrueSolutionsA variant of dog foods in the Blue Buffalo product line
PriceFairly costlyVery Expensive
SafetyVery many food recalls, 9 to be exact (2007 – 2017 )Voluntary recalled once in 2017

Verdict: Overall, Blue Wilderness contains more nutrients but the ideal choice depends on which suits your dog’s needs.