Clicky

Blue Buffalo vs. Canidae 2022

Blue Buffalo vs. Canidae

Both Canidae and Blue Buffalo use excellent ingredients to make their pet foods which explains why they are among the most reputable brands in the market. But there must, however, be factors that make one better than the other. So, who wins in the showdown?

Blue Buffalo vs. Canidae Companies

Since its founding in 1996, San Luis Obispo, CA, the U.S. by John Gordon and Scott Whipple, Canidae has made a name for itself for the production of high-quality and reliable pet foods. In fact, the brand has very many positive reviews which would explain their fame in the pet food industry. They even have Canidae Farms where they grow their ingredients for making pet foods.

On the other hand, Blue Buffalo was founded more than a decade after Merrick in 2003 by Bill Bishop and in 2018, it was sold to General Mills. It is headquartered in Connecticut, USA but has operations in more than 5 countries.

Blue Buffalo vs. Canidae Ingredients

The two brands seem to tie with minimal difference in the dry matter basis of both cat and dog foods. Canidae has 0.7%, 1.7%, 0.8%, and 3.9% higher protein content in dry dog food, wet dog food, dry cat food, and wet cat foods. This gives it more nutritional value than Blue Buffalo. They use good ingredients but both have 4 common controversial ones. However, Canidae has 3 unique against Blue Buffalo’s 4 controversial ingredients in their diets. On the one hand, Canidae has been recalled once for salmonella contamination against Blue Buffalo’s 9 times.

Blue Buffalo vs. Canidae Pricing

And while their pricing is almost similar, Canidae’s wet dog food is very expensive compared to Blue’s.

Blue Buffalo vs. Canidae Comparison Table

FactorBlue BuffaloCanidae
TasteUses meats for great taste enriched with veggiesFocuses on real meats plus some veggies for a great taste
Nutritional ValueHigh-quality ingredients with zero fillers but has some ingredients that are very controversialReceives loads of positive reviews due to quality ingredients. Has higher fat and protein content.
Product LineSix product lines: Freedom, Basics, Veterinary Diet, Wilderness, Carnivora & TrueSolutions57 dog food products & 17 cat food products
PriceFairly costlyExpensive
SafetyVery many recalls, 9 to be exact (2007 – 2017 )One recall in 2016

Blue Buffalo Freedom vs Canidae Pure Elements (video)

Verdict:

Overall, both brands are good choices but we lean more on Canidae despite the high price tags due to the nutritional value and safety.

Blue Buffalo vs. Blue Wilderness 2022

Blue Wilderness is one of Blue Buffalo’s categories of pet foods but we’ll delve into the differences in this article.

Blue Wilderness vs Blue Buffalo

Blue Wilderness brand has high protein composition and is grain-free while Blue Buffalo is composed of proteins and fewer protein ingredients. That’s the major difference between the two Blue Wilderness having a higher amount of protein content and all formulas are grain-free.

Also, Blue Buffalo contains both dog and cat foods but Blue Wilderness is a variant of the brand’s dog foods. It tries to mimic your pet’s instinctive diet which mainly contains meat. To enhance the food’s taste, the brand uses natural flavors like Parsley and Rosemary.

Both the Blue Wilderness and regular Blue Buffalo line of products consist of LifeSource Bits which is an ideal blend of vitamins, minerals, and antioxidants. This helps support a healthy immune system and promote overall health. As you would expect, there would be a significant difference in the products depending on what you choose. Unlike regular Blue Buffalo products, Blue Wilderness contains less omega-6 fatty acids but more crude fat and fiber.

Blue Buffalo vs. Blue Wilderness Comparison Table

FactorBlue BuffaloBlue Wilderness
TasteUses meat, has tasty meals, but that differs based on recipesContains higher protein and fat contents making it more palatable
Nutritional ValueHigh-quality ingredients with zero fillers & include omegasMore nutritious with healthy ingredients, omegas & no fillers
Product LineSix product lines: Freedom, Basics, Veterinary Diet, Wilderness, Carnivora & TrueSolutionsA variant of dog foods in the Blue Buffalo product line
PriceFairly costlyVery Expensive
SafetyVery many food recalls, 9 to be exact (2007 – 2017 )Voluntary recalled once in 2017

Verdict: Overall, Blue Wilderness contains more nutrients but the ideal choice depends on which suits your dog’s needs.

Blue Buffalo vs. Merrick 2022

Both Merrick and Blue Buffalo are good pet food brands with an emphasis on the quality and wellness of your pets. Right from their origins, the two have a lot in common, but that does not make them equal. So, which is better between Blue Buffalo vs. Merrick in the showdown?

Blue Buffalo vs. Merrick

Merrick rose from humble beginnings in 1988 as an independent operation founded by Garth Merrick. Garth began with homemade meals for Gracie, his dog, and his neighbors started ordering some as well which is when he started mass production. The company was acquired by Nestle Purina PetCare Corp. in 2015.

On the other hand, Blue Buffalo was founded more than a decade after Merrick in 2003 by Bill Bishop and in 2018, it was sold to General Mills. It is headquartered in Connecticut, USA but has operations in more than 5 countries.

Blue Buffalo vs. Merrick Infredients

Blue Buffalo and Merrick use natural healthy ingredients which make their pet foods nutritious and tasty. There are no cheap fillers in the two brands thus improving their nutritional value. Yet, Merrick has higher protein content in their diets. Their dry dog, wet cat, dry cat, and wet cat foods have 6.5%, 3.9%, 3.5%, and 0.9% more protein than Blue Buffalo. However, we noted controversial ingredients in both with 3 unique in each and one with adverse health effects.

Blue Buffalo vs. Merrick Recalls

In terms of recalls, Merrick only has 6 against Blue Buffalo’s 9.

Blue Buffalo vs. Merrick Pricing

And while the prices are almost similar, Blue Buffalo is less costly.

Blue Buffalo vs. Merrick Comparison Table

FactorBlue BuffaloMerrick
TasteUses meat, has tasty meals, but that differs based on recipesUse more meat with more protein content making tasty meals
Nutritional ValueHigh-quality ingredients with zero fillers & include omegasMore nutritious with healthy ingredients, omegas & no fillers
Product LineSix product lines: Freedom, Basics, Veterinary Diet, Wilderness, Carnivora & TrueSolutionsTen product lines in total for both dog and cat foods
PriceFairly costlyVery Expensive
SafetyVery many food recalls, 9 to be exact (2007 – 2017 )Six recalls from 2010 to 2018

Verdict: Blue Buffalo vs. Merrick

Overall, both brands are good choices but we pick Merrick due to safety concerns and high protein content, and high nutritional value.

Blue Buffalo vs. NutriSource 2022

Both Blue Buffalo and NutriSource are well-known brands in the pet foods market. They provide high-quality dog and cat foods. They both mostly use healthy ingredients which is why they stand out. But that is not enough to make them the best. So, what is the difference?

Blue Buffalo vs. NutriSource Companies

Nutro was founded in 1947 in Perham, Minnesota under the name Pine Lakes Feed Company by Darrell ‘Tuffy’ Nelson. Kenny, Darrell’s son, partnered with his dad after graduating from college to create Tuffy’s Dog Food Company which has expanded and grown tremendously since. NutriSource is currently under the KLN Family Brands.

Nutrisource  vs Buffalo food brands

Blue Buffalo was founded in 2003 by Bill Bishop and has been known as a natural pet food company producing natural dog food and treats such as BLUE Life Protection Formula, BLUE Wilderness, BLUE Basics, BLUE Freedom, and BLUE Natural Veterinary Diet lines. In 2018, Blue Buffalo was sold to General Mills which has managed to grow its sales 10% annually from 2018 to 2021.

Blue Buffalo vs. NutriSource Nutrition/Ingredients

On the one hand, NutriSource has the upper hand when it comes to protein content. It offers 3.3%, 1.2%, and 1.0% more protein than Blue’s wet dog food, wet cat food, and dry dog food. Blue Buffalo exceeds NutriSource at dry cat foods with 0.3%.

Blue Buffalo vs. NutriSource Pricing

When it comes to price, both brands are affordable but NutriSource is on the lower end of the spectrum.

Blue Buffalo vs. NutriSource Suitability

Blue Buffalo’s line of products is suitable for all types of dogs, unlike NutriSource which is unfit for hunting dogs. In addition, the brand is not easily accessible like Blue Buffalo. The latter also offers a range of flavors with its 339 recipes against NutriSource 69. However, the latter has zero recalls.

Blue Buffalo vs. NutriSource Comparison Table

FactorBlue BuffaloNutriSource 
TasteUses real meat as the primary ingredient. Premium ingredients.Uses meat as the first ingredient sometimes & wholesome grains
FoundedFounded in 1947Founded in 2003
Nutritional ValueOnly exceeds NutriSource cat food protein content with 0.3%Leads in terms of protein content in wet dog & cat foods plus dry dog food
Product LineSix product lines: Freedom, Basics, Veterinary Diet, Wilderness, Carnivora & TrueSolutions
PriceCan be costlyScience Diets are very expensive
Product SafetyVery many Blue Buffalo food recalls (2007 – 2017 ).ZERO recalls

Verdict: Blue Buffalo vs. NutriSource

Overall, both brands offer protein-rich recipes which are balanced for all life stages but Blue Buffalo prevails in flavor variety. And while not readily available, NutriSource is cost-effective and safe (without recalls) which is why we choose it.

Blue Buffalo vs. Nutro 2022

Blue Buffalo vs. Nutro

Both Blue Buffalo and Nutro are brands that make high-end pet foods in terms of quality. In fact, the two are very impossible to tell apart in many aspects. So, which are these identical features, and who wins the contest?

Blue Buffalo vs. Nutro Companies

Nutro was started in 1926 by John Saleen, an entrepreneur who purchased a dog food company to manufacture healthy kibble for Southern Carolina residents. The brand is one of the most popular quality foods you will find in pet food stores in the US. The pet food company was family-owned and operated until 1976 when it was acquired by Mars, Inc., Pedigree brand owner. It prospered after purchase and has facilities in Tennessee, California, and Missouri.

Blue Buffalo was founded in 2003 by Bill Bishop who later sold it to General Mills in 2018. It is headquartered in Wilton, Connecticut, USA.

Blue Buffalo vs. Nutro Overview & Recalls

When it comes to palatability, both Nutro and Blue Buffalo offer great foods but the latter is on the higher end of the spectrum, especially with its high-protein line of foods. Although Nutro’s ingredient splitting method is a concern, we give it thumbs up for great safety records. Unlike Blue, Nutro has only been recalled twice in the past decade. Both brands offer their foods at a competitive price with a range of selections to suit your pet’s needs.

Blue Buffalo vs. Nutro Ingredients & Nutrition

On the one hand, their cat food guaranteed analysis is almost the same with a slight difference visible in their wet foods in terms of protein contents (54.6%B and 45.6%N). This applies in their dog foods with Blue at 29.5% protein content in dry dog food against Nutro’s 27%.  Canned dog foods have 40% and 42.6% (Blue & Nutro) in protein content.

Blue Buffalo vs. Nutro Comparison Table

FactorBlue BuffaloNutro
TasteUses real meat as the primary ingredient. Premium ingredients.Uses meat as the first ingredient sometimes & wholesome grains
Nutritional ValueUses less controversial ingredients: Canola oil, caramel & garlicHas many controversial ingredients in its formulas
Product LineSix product lines: Freedom, Basics, Veterinary Diet, Wilderness, Carnivora & TrueSolutionsTen product lines in total for both dog and cat foods
PriceCan be costlyCan be expensive
SafetyVery many food recalls, 9 to be exact (2007 – 2017 )Four major recalls in 2007, 2010, 2015, 2016 & 2017

Verdict: Blue Buffalo vs. Nutro

Overall, both have a significant number of controversial ingredients in their formula. But we pick Nutro over Blue Buffalo due to safety concerns. If your dog prefers Blue, he knows best.

Blue Buffalo vs Science Diet 2022

Both Blue Buffalo and Science Diet are excellent brands with comparable price points which explain why they fall under the same category. They manufacture premium pet foods that are safe for your pets but that does not mean they are similar. So, who is better in the face-off?

Blue Buffalo vs Science Diet Companies

Hill’s Pet Nutrition, the marketer of Science Diet, entered the pet food market in the 1930s. The company’s story is quite interesting! A dog owner requested a prominent vet to make dog food that would help his dog diagnosed with kidney failure. They did so successfully and that was the dawn of the brand’s journey which you popularly recognize today.

On the other hand, Blue Buffalo was founded in 2003 by Bill Bishop who later sold it to General Mills in 2018. It is headquartered in Wilton, Connecticut, USA.

Blue Buffalo vs Science Diet Ingredients

The major difference between Blue Buffalo and Science Diet is in the ingredients. While Blue uses natural ingredients without by-products, Hill’s foods are based on science (not always natural). And while Hill’s uses real meat as the first ingredient, it is not guaranteed as with Blue, plus they use meat by-products which are controversial ingredients. Unlike Blue, all Hill’s diets are grain-inclusive and are transparent with their clients.

Blue Buffalo vs. Science Diet Comparison Table

FactorBlue BuffaloScience Diet
TasteUses real meat as the primary ingredient. Premium ingredients.Uses meat as the first ingredient sometimes & wholesome grains
Nutritional Value30% minimum protein, 15% fat, 4.5% fiber & 10% moisture29% minimum protein, 15% fat, 15% fiber & 10% moisture
Product LineSix product lines: Freedom, Basics, Veterinary Diet, Wilderness, Carnivora & TrueSolutionsFour product lines in total: Science Diet is popular with 42 dry kibble recipes & 16 wet foods
PriceCan be costlyScience Diets are very expensive
SafetyVery many food recalls (2007 – 2017 )Three major recall in June 2014, January 2019 & March 2019

Dog Testing Food Comparison of Blue Buffalo vs Science Diet

Verdict: Blue Buffalo vs Science Diet

Overall, both brands are okay, but it depends on what you are looking for. If you prefer all grain-inclusive formulas, Hill’s is a go. If you need many options, Blue is ideal.